VARDAMAN VIRTUAL FORESTRY COMPANY

The Most Direct Link to Knowledge Workers in the Southeast Forest Economy


Home
Friday Report
PTAEDA2V
Selling Land/Timber
Investments
Pine Plantations
Genetics
Fertilization
Stumpage Prices
JMV's Book
Links








Google

Search WWW Search vardaman.com


PPIC® AND LIC: NEW PURE-TIMBER INVESTMENTS

A Pine Plantation Investment Contractâ , in its standard form, is a vehicle by which an individual can invest as little as $40,000 in timber or, in a batch of which, an institution can invest $100,000,000. Both can pay for purchases in installments. As investments, PPIC’s have several advantages over the typical tract of timberland: 1) they do not require sinking capital into land, 2) every square foot of growing space is utilized, 3) they are located on public roads and can be logged 12 months of the year, 4) they utilize loblolly pine, the most-widely-distributed species in the South, and 5) the timber they produce is bought daily in enormous quantities and therefore easy to appraise.

The predicted compound, annual return of a standard PPIC varies with the characteristics of each one. Attached as an illustration is the schedule of cash flows through a single PPIC, AL93270WG_, a 270-acre tract in Alabama planted in January 1993. Its predicted return as a standard PPIC is 11.85%. As of 1/1/99, it required a down payment of $88,420, the total costs plus interest of Pine Plantation Management Company (PPMC) at that date. All future costs (landowner payment, management, inspection, reports, and record keeping) are included in the Annual Payments. Details of 29 PPIC’s including maps, photos, and cash-flow schedules appear on http://www.se-timbersales.com/.

The Insured PPIC

The main drawback of a PPIC in early years while the trees are growing to merchantable size is a lack of liquidity. To eliminate this, we have developed a Liquidity Insurance Contract (LIC) that allows the Investor to liquidate it at specified prices after making the annual payment on 12/31 each year. Insured PPIC’s are predicted to yield a compound, annual return of 9% above inflation and have additional benefits for taxable investors. The table below shows how this works in the case of AL93270WG_. Down payment is $205,000; annual payments are $36,720. The amount that the Investor will receive by liquidating his PPIC after making the annual payment on 12/31 each year appear in the right-hand column. Since PPIC’s were designed as long-term commitments and not for in-and-out trading, the return the Investor will receive at premature liquidation will be only 3% initially and will rise as he continues to hold it.

Here are scheduled cash flows:

Total
1/1

Invest

Cash-in
Factor

12/31
Total

+Pymnt
Income

12/31
Total

99

205,000

1.030

211,150

+36,720

247,870

00

247,870

1.035

256,545

"

293,265

01

293,265

1.040

304,996

"

341,716

02

341,716

1.045

357,093

"

393,813

03

393,813

1.050

413,504

"

450,224

04

450,224

1.055

474,986

-35,961

439,025

05

439,025

1.060

465,367

+36,720

502,087

06

502,087

1.065

534,722

"

571,442

07

571,442

1.070

611,443

"

648,163

08

648,163

"

693,535

"

730,255

09

730,225

"

781,373

"

818,093

10

818,093

"

912,079

"

912,079

11

912,079

"

975,925

"

1,012,645

12

1,012,645

"

1,083,530

"

1,120,250

3 Less than amount that could be obtained by selling timber (see below)

Two other factors must be mentioned. First, for some Investors the interest portion of the Annual Payments is deductible, and the profit from timber sales is taxable as a long-term gain. Second, the Underwriter retains an option to buy future timber sales for the predicted prices plus annual inflation as measured by the CPI-U. Therefore, the Investor will earn 9% above inflation, but will not participate in any additional rises in timber prices.

The Liquidity Insurance Contract

Since there is now no public market for PPIC’s, the Liquidity Insurance Contract (LIC) satisfies the demands of Investors who are required by regulations or other considerations to have guaranteed liquidity. Underwriters of LIC’s are often timber manufacturers that will need as future raw material the trees being grown, but that do not have the huge amounts of capital required to buy land and grow their own. The LIC is unique in that it pays timber industries to help investors grow the timber that the industries will need later.

At the time of the sale of AL93270WG_ to an Investor as an Insured PPIC, PPMC paid $120,000 of the purchase price to an Underwriter. The following table sets forth in detail the income and obligations of the Underwriter in this case:


1/1

Total

Costs

X
1.1185

+pymnt
-Income

Cal.Val.
on 12/31

LIC Prm
x 1.08

Total
Value

99

88,420'

98,898

+36,720

135,618

129,600

265,218

00

135,618

151,689

"

188,409

139,968

328,377

01

188,409

210,735

"

247,455

151,165

398,620

02

247,455

276,778

"

313,498

163,259

476,757

03

313,498

350,648

"

387,368

176,319

563,687

04

387,368

433,270

-35,961

397,310

190,425

587,732

05

397,310

444,391

+36,720

481,111

205,659

686,770

06

481,111

538,122

"

574,842

222,112

796,954

07

574,842

642,961

"

679,681

239,881

919,562

08

679,681

760,223

"

796,943

259,071

1,056,014

09

796,943

891,381

"

928,101

279,797

1,207,898

10

928,101

1,038,081

"

1,074,801

302,180

1,376,981

11

1,074,801

1,202,165

"

1,238,885

326,355

1,565,240

12. Timber can be sold for more than the liquidation value

1 Total PPMC costs plus interest at 1/1/99
2 Essentially equal to Liquidation Value

Volume of merchantable timber on the PPICâ increases rapidly in volume after 2004 because the best trees have been released from competition by the poor-quality and undersized ones and because they have been fertilized. Its value increases at a much faster rate because trees once large enough only for pulpwood soon become large enough for sawtimber. Market value of timber remaining after the thinning = $170,370. Value at harvest 10 years later = $1,921,274, a compound annual increase of 27.4%. Values by years are as follows:

2004

$170,370

2008

$448,817

2012

$1,182,355

2005

217,051

2009

571,794

2013

1,506,320

2006

276,523

2010

728,465

2014

1,919,052

2007

352,290

2011

928,065

 

 

One provision of the PPIC allows the Landowner to buy back his contract by paying all PPMC costs plus interest at 10% plus the inflation rate compounded monthly. When buy-back occurs, the Investor gets an unexpected bonus, and the Underwriter’s obligation terminates early.

The LIC does not cover losses from fire, windstorm, or insects; the Investor can reduce risks of loss from these sources by buying a batch of PPIC’s. By the nature of the LIC, the Underwriter bears risks from price declines and incorrect growth predictions.

If one of these three investments interests you, please call Jim Vardaman at 800+455-4568 for more information.